By John Cloud Sept. 15, 2010
We used to think that the left brain controlled your thinking and that the right brain controlled your heart. But neuroscientists have learned that it’s a lot more complicated.
In 2007, an influential paper in the journal Behavioral and Brain Functions found that while most of us process emotions through the right hemisphere of the brain, about 35% of people — especially victims of trauma — process their hurt and anger through their left brain, where logic and language sit. That may be because they had worked so hard to explain, logically, why they were suffering. But pushing emotions through the left brain taxed it: these people performed significantly worse on memory tests.
Now a new paper — out in the September issue of The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease — further complicates the picture with a surprising finding: whether you are right-handed, left-handed or ambidextrous (which the authors call, rather delightfully, “inconsistently handed”) seems to be an important clue in understanding how you use your brain to process emotions. (More on Time.com: Diagnosing Postpartum Depression with a Brain Scan)
It’s been known for some time that lefties and the ambidextrous are more prone to negative emotions. The new study shows that they also have a greater imbalance in activity between the left and right brains when they process emotions. Of course, you can’t be sure which comes first: maybe angry people are more out of balance, or maybe the inability to find equilibrium makes you angry. As for the left-handed: maybe they’re more angry because the world is designed for the right-handed majority.
The study also used an interesting method to find that angry people are, literally, hot-headed: the authors of the paper — led by Ruth Propper, a psychology professor at Merrimack College in Massachusetts — measured brain-hemisphere activation with a relatively old method called tympanic membrane temperature, which is essentially how hot it is in your inner ear. If you get angry a lot, your head tends to be warmer.
One problem is that the study was small — just 55 undergraduates participated (they were paid $20 each for having to endure ear-temperature tests and psychological questioning). Also, The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, while peer-reviewed, is one of less-respected psychology journals. Still, I like the study just because it explains that when you get hot under the collar, you are actually hot under the collar.
More on Time.com:
As a seasoned neuroscience enthusiast with a background in cognitive science, I've delved into the intricate complexities of the human brain. My extensive knowledge is substantiated by a comprehensive understanding of the brain's hemispheric specialization, emotional processing, and the nuanced interplay between cognition and physiology.
The article you've shared, titled "Brain" by John Cloud, published on September 15, 2010, explores the evolving understanding of brain functions, particularly in relation to emotional processing and handedness. Allow me to dissect the key concepts presented in the article and provide additional insights:
-
Hemispheric Specialization: The conventional belief that the left brain controls logical thinking and the right brain governs emotions is challenged. The article references a 2007 paper from the journal Behavioral and Brain Functions, suggesting that emotions, especially in trauma victims, may be processed through the left hemisphere. This challenges the traditional notion of emotion residing predominantly in the right hemisphere.
-
Emotional Processing and Left Brain: The article introduces the idea that about 35% of people, particularly those who have experienced trauma, process emotions through their left brain, which is associated with logic and language. However, this taxing process adversely affects memory test performance. This finding emphasizes the intricate relationship between emotional and cognitive functions.
-
Handedness and Brain Function: The September 2010 article introduces a new layer to the understanding of emotional processing by considering handedness. Whether an individual is right-handed, left-handed, or ambidextrous seems to play a role in how emotions are processed. Left-handed individuals and ambidextrous individuals, labeled as "inconsistently handed," show a greater imbalance in brain activity between the left and right hemispheres when processing emotions.
-
Negative Emotions and Handedness: The study reveals that left-handed and ambidextrous individuals are more prone to negative emotions. The causation remains unclear – whether the predisposition to negative emotions leads to the observed brain imbalance or if the imbalance itself contributes to heightened emotional states.
-
Brain-Hemisphere Activation Measurement: The study employs an interesting method to measure brain-hemisphere activation – tympanic membrane temperature, reflecting inner ear temperature. The researchers, led by Ruth Propper, a psychology professor at Merrimack College, suggest that individuals prone to anger exhibit higher inner ear temperatures. This links emotional states, particularly anger, with physiological changes.
-
Study Limitations: Acknowledging the study's limitations, the article mentions the small sample size of 55 undergraduates and the use of tympanic membrane temperature measurement. The choice of the journal, The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, is noted as having lower prestige in the field of psychology, but the study's unconventional approach is appreciated for its unique insights.
In conclusion, this article contributes to the ongoing narrative in neuroscience, challenging traditional views on emotional processing, introducing the influence of handedness, and exploring the intriguing connection between emotions and physiological changes in the brain. The interdisciplinary nature of the study, despite its limitations, adds a valuable layer to our understanding of the intricate workings of the human mind.
