We Found the 13 Best Flours for Any Type of Recipe (2024)

We Found the 13 Best Flours for Any Type of Recipe (1)

When you’re in a pinch (of sugar) or the kind of bind only gluten can relate to, any flour just might do. Whether you’re baking bread, making pizza, becoming the next best pastry chef, or whipping up a gourmet meal, you’ll reach for any flour you can get your hands on if you’re short on available options. However, not all flour is created equally, and when you have the luxury of choice, it’s worth finding the very best flour base for the best outcomes. Because, you see, "baking is a science," "while "cooking is an art," so the flour you choose really does have an impact on how good your end result is.

Do you want your bread to be chewy and toothsome? Your biscuits flaky, scones crumbly, or your cakes cloudlike? The flour you use will contribute to all of the above and more. So, we’re providing our best recommendations for whatever science project your kitchen lab is destined to "proof" next.

Our Top Picks

Jump to Review
Jump to Review

In This Article

  • Our Picks

  • What to Look for

  • FAQs

  • How We Selected

  • Why Trust The Spruce Eats?

What We Like

  • Organic

  • Same protein content for each batch

  • Versatile

What We Don't Like

  • Bag can leak

This flour just hits a lot of checkboxes, both in terms of ethical, conscious consumerism and material quality. Employee-owned? Check. Organic? Check. Minimally treated? Diligently sourced? American to its core? Service-oriented? All yesses. The only con we can come up with for this flour is that the bag can leak, but as any seasoned home baker knows, that is the case with most flours. A trick is to empty the bag of flour into a proper storage container. (Here is one of our favorites.)

As for performance, the brand prides itself on having a precisely calibrated, right-in-the-middle formula (that feeds the whole family, including the furry ones), which means that every bag in every batch will have the same exact 11.7 percent protein content and same soft and hard wheat proportion. This, in turn, means that your perfected recipe will never go awry as long as you stay loyal. Consistency, thine name is King Arthur All-Purpose, a flour that truly lives up to its multitasking claim.

Size: 10 pounds | Type of wheat: Hard Red Wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: 11.7 percent

On the far side of the spectrum lies bread flour, which has a 12 to 14 percent protein level for a strong gluten network once activated. This results in more structural integrity, which means greater heft, chew, and density. Another attractive side effect is more browning in the crust and bigger open crumbs—the better to melt butter into. Bob’s Red Mill’s Artisan Bread Flour is ideal for bread of all types, including sourdough, baguettes, and rustic loaves, as well as pretzels, bagels, and more, because of its high protein content.

Every package’s exact percentage varies based on its source but has been tested to typically scale on the higher range. Its wheat is also mixed with a little malted barley as an added bonus—this ingredient helps yeast breads rise.

Size: 5 pounds | Type of wheat: Wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: 12.5-13.5 percent

What We Like

  • More nutrient dense

  • Doesn't need a lot of kneading

  • Organic

What We Don't Like

  • Needs water

Whole wheat flour, with its naturally more nutrient-dense profile, nuttier taste, and heartier feel, shines when made into rustic bread, provided it’s not overworked to toughness. Be careful not to knead it more than you "knead" to. It also does well in earthier applications, such as carrot cake, gingerbread, muffins, dinner rolls, crackers, zucchini bread, and the like.

Arrowhead Mills’ stone-ground, organic, non-GMO whole wheat flour is a good choice for any of these projects, with a milder nuttiness than others, such as the high 14.5 percent Great River organic whole wheat flour—a top contender for this category title. As with any whole-wheat flour, though, be sure to add a little extra water to your recipe—it has a thirsty character that performs better when slaked.

Size: 1.5 pounds | Type of wheat: Whole wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: Not indicated

What We Like

  • Nice color

  • Firm

  • Imported from Naples, Italy

What We Don't Like

  • Bag not resealable

Many chefs and pasta makers are happy to use the same 00 flour for stretchy noodles as they do for their pizza crusts, but for that lovely pale yellow color, a superior nutritional profile, and high protein/gluten elasticity, durum wheat semolina flour can’t be beaten. It’s the hardest of all U.S. wheat varieties and comes in a coarser grind, which makes it more nutritionally dense, nuttier tasting, and naturally firmer, thus holding on better to the shape you will it to take.

All of the above is why dry semolina pasta has been a supermarket mainstay for national brands in the U.S. for decades. But anything they can do, you can do better—make your own authentic fresh pasta with this imported flour from Naples and capture the true taste of Italy for dinner. Because you most likely will only use it for pasta, we don't love that the bag isn't resealable to keep it fresh in the pantry. Using an airtight storage container is a good idea.

Size: 2.2 pounds | Type of wheat: Durum wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: 12.5 percent

The 5 Best Pasta Drying Racks We Tested

What We Like

  • Contains baking powder and salt

  • Made with hard and soft wheats

  • Pairs well with butter and salt

What We Don't Like

  • Not great for baking bread

Typically a blend of hard and soft wheats, baking powder, and salt, self-rising flour proportions vary from brand to brand. But if you want height and want it light 100 percent soft winter white blend is the way to go, especially since it’s now available in unbleached form. You’ll need 2 tablespoons extra of this flour per cup to make up for its all-soft composition, but that additional calculation is worth the result—taste tests have concluded that it enhances butter and salt flavors in baked goods noticeably, making it the number one choice of Southern bakers for biscuits for generations.

While we don’t recommend using this for bread, it will gift your non-yeasted baked goods with airy oomph and anything you should make with it a soft, smooth texture. However, if you use it, do it within six months to get the most out of the baking powder in it while storing it in one of our favorite tested food storage containers.

Size: 5 pounds | Type of wheat: Winter wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: Typically 8.5 percent

What We Like

  • Great in-between flour

  • Cookies keep their shape

  • Slightly sweet

What We Don't Like

  • Not great for heftier baking

Pastry flour creates a lighter, softer cookie, while bread flour results in a denser finished product with crunchy edges and more chew. However, the perfect cookie ought to have elements of both, which makes this hard winter wheat blend just right. Cookies made with this flour retain their size and shape well, spreading just enough to create a crisp circle without becoming an amorphous blob. Tests have noted that a slightly sweet quality enhances vanilla flavors particularly well with this flour, making it even more of a stronger pick for cookie time.

Size: 5 pounds | Type of wheat: Hard red winter wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: About 12 percent

What We Like

  • Low in gluten

  • Reliable brand

  • Rises nicely

What We Don't Like

  • Can't use as an all-purpose flour substitute

For anything that remotely resembles cake, to get the most delicate, airy crumb, you’ll want to go with low-gluten cake flour. Whether you’re making angel, layer, pound, pudding, sheet, cup-, pan- or any other type of confection that ends in "cake," this retro-looking box of flour has been proud to be the brand of choice since 1894, particularly in the American South. What makes it so special is that it’s sifted repeatedly for a grain that’s "27 times finer than all-purpose flour," which helps create a moisture-holding, tender crumb, and a fluffy rise perfect for any application that calls for light flavor and low density. Because of this, it isn't a good substitute should you need all-purpose flour.

Size: 2 pounds | Type of wheat: Winter wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Bleached | Protein Content: 8-9 percent

We Baked 19 Cakes to Find the Best Bundt Pans

What We Like

  • Solid mixture

  • 1:1 ratio

  • Doesn't affect flavor

What We Don't Like

  • Some may find it dry

Baking with gluten-free flour doesn't mean you have to sacrifice flavor or texture—especially when the gluten-free flour you use is from the experts at King Arthur. The company's GF flour mix combines rice, brown rice, and whole sorghum flour with tapioca and potato starch to thicken, and a vitamin and mineral blend to mimic fortified versions of the real thing. Some may find it slightly dry, but one cup fits in perfectly as a substitute for one cup of all-purpose or whole wheat flour in any recipe.

Size: 3 pounds | Type of wheat: Made with rice, brown rice, and whole sorghum flour | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: About 9 percent

The 9 Best Gluten-Free Bread Mixes of 2024

What We Like

  • Ground very finely

  • Strong gluten makes stretchy dough

  • High cooking temperature is ideal

What We Don't Like

  • Best when cooked at a high temperature

Pizzaiolos chasing after the Neapolitan standard and that perfect leopard-spotted thin crust will often proudly boast of their use of 00 flour. And for good reason! This extremely fine-ground soft wheat flour has a 12.5 percent protein content that lets the pizza dough stretch to remarkable, pliable, and appropriately cheese-pull lengths for optimal results. One thing to note is that once it is made into pizza dough, it should be cooked at a high temperature like 500-600 degrees Fahrenheit. This is both good and potentially tricky—good because you'll get an authentic, thin pizza with a charred crust, but if you don't have a pizza oven, it may be hard to get your regular oven hot enough. (If you're looking for a pizza oven, we tested nearly two dozen and found the 10 best ones.)

Those serious about their pizza should opt for this 00 by Caputo, a third-generation miller right in Naples that has been trusted since 1924 to help create pizza crust perfection using a blend of meticulously sourced wheats from Italy and northern Europe. It doesn’t get more authentic than this.

Size: 2.2 pounds | Type of wheat: Soft wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: 12.5 percent

We Tested the Best Pizza Stones and Found the Best Ones for Crispier Crusts

What We Like

  • Bright white color

  • Softer

  • Fluffy once baked

What We Don't Like

  • Bag is thin

For when color—or lack thereof—doesmatter, this bleached flour is a great choice. Instances of when you might want bright white flour are for projects likepillowy dumplings, pierogies,mantou for bao, and cakes such asangel food, white, or ones where you want added dye colors to really pop. Beyond aesthetics, this flour undergoes a bleaching process that speeds up the flour’s aging process, breaks down gluten, and creates a softer flour for more volume.

This makes bleached all-purpose popular among Southern bakers, and this iconic baking brand is a longstanding favorite found at many grocery stores and online marketplaces. Like some other flours, the bag is thin and prone to ripping, so handle with care.

Size: 2 pounds | Type of wheat: White flour | Bleached or Unbleached: Bleached | Protein Content: 10-11 percent

What we Like

  • 1:1 swap

  • Sweet, nutty flavor

  • Finely ground

  • More expensive

The number of alternative flours has risen in recent years, but one of the easiest swaps to make is with almond flour. It is slightly more expensive than other flours, butthis nutty, naturally gluten-free flour is moist, slightly sweet, and bitter and can replace regular flour in a recipe 1:1. Blue Diamond's version is finely ground and sifted, too, so using it won't alter the texture of your cookies, bread, or biscuits. Store it in the fridge for six months or the freezer for a year to keep it fresh for longer.

Size: 3 pounds | Type of wheat: Made of almond flour | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: Not indicated

What We Like

  • Made in Thailand

  • Trusted brand

  • Cost-effective

What We Don't Like

  • Not suitable for bread making

For lack of a better category name, we just wanted to point out that if you’re looking for flour in non-wheat territory, Erawan is the brand to buy next time you’re confused at an Asian market’s wealth of rice and tapioca starches. This line is made by Sun Wah Foods and trusted by Asian chefs around the world, making it consistent and accessible. It can be used to make a lot of things, but isn't great for bread, as there is no gluten and it won't rise.

Size: 1 pound | Type of wheat: Finely milled white raw rice | Bleached or Unbleached: Not applicable | Protein Content: Not applicable

What We Like

  • Consistent

  • Widely available

  • Can be used in baking bread or a cake

What We Don't Like

  • Bag can rip easily

This supermarket staple brand is consistent in its right-in-the-middle 10.5 percent protein content, and its original blue-label bleached version is readily available pretty much anywhere. A very neutral blend, the slight hint of pleasant nuttiness that shows up in crunchy bakes is what edges it out over other easy-to-access, affordable lines. If you can, always choose the less-processed unbleached version because the color of the flour doesn’t matter in cooking, and bleaching can sometimes mar what you make with a slight metallic taste you might recognize from flours that sit in your pantry for too long. This is another flour that comes in a thin, paper bag, so be mindful when handling because it can rip.

Editor's Note: In April 2023, General Mills issued a recall of 5- and 10-pound bags of the Unbleached and Bleached All Purpose Flour with "better if used by" dates of March 27, 2024 and March 28, 2024 after Salmonella Infantisis was discovered in the flour. Be sure to check any bags you may have at home and any you purchase in the store and online for the affected "better if used by" dates. For more information about the recall, please visit the FDA's website.

Size: 5 pounds | Type of wheat: Wheat | Bleached or Unbleached: Unbleached | Protein Content: 10.5 percent

Final Verdict

For those who don’t want to stock their pantries with several different types of flour, you can’t go wrong with King Arthur Organic All-Purpose Flour, which is extremely versatile and will provide consistent results. For any gluten-free cooking you may be doing (or if you like a more nutty taste in your recipes) we recommend Blue Diamond Almond Flour.

What to Look for in Flour

Use

If you are going to bake cookies, muffins, and brownies, you will want a good, all-purpose flour that ranges in the 10 to 12 percent protein range. If you're going to make sturdier products, such as bread, pizza, and pasta, you'll look to semolina, tipo 00, whole-wheat and/or bread flours. (These flours have a higher protein content than all-purpose flour). Finally, for cakes and delicate pastries, you'll look for pastry and cake flours.

Processing

You may have seen words such as bleached, unbleached, bromated, and pre-sifted on bags of flour before. These words will give you a clue as to how the flour will look and taste once it's used and baked. Seek out those that are marked whole grain, stone-ground, and/or unbleached if you prefer products that are as wholesome and unprocessed as possible. If you can find locally or regionally milled flour, it will taste even fresher, and that will be evident in your baked goods—especially when it comes to homemade bread.

Quantity

Don't buy more flour than you need. If you find yourself in a situation where you can buy some good local flour and you want to stock up but you're not sure how quickly you'll go through it, you can always freeze flour. Freshness is especially important if the flour is whole grain. They still contain the bran of the grain and will therefore go rancid faster than all-purpose white flour.

Protein

Protein, not varietal—like hard, soft, red, or white—is how we categorize flour in America. Why? Because gluten. This much-maligned protein varietal is what gives flour-based goods the springy, toothsome, or crumbly texture we love. It’s formed when gliadin and glutenin bond to one another with the addition of liquid; the more bonds that form, the more structure your project will.

The difference in percentages may vary by as little as 5 to 10 percent...but when we’re talking about microscopic molecules, it makes a major difference. In the middle, all-purpose blends offer 8 to 11.25 percent, depending on the brand.

FAQs

How do you make self-rising flour?

Self-rising flour isn’t a magically levitating substance—all it means is that salt and baking powder have been added to it already in all-purpose proportions. However, because the rise is the highlight of this flour, it’s typically made with a lower protein base for a more tender result. To make your own, choose a soft wheat flour and add 1 1/2 teaspoons of baking powder and 1/4 teaspoon of salt to every cup.

Does flour expire?

Well, it all comes down to protein and storage. If kept airtight and away from light, the average all-purpose flour can sit in your pantry for around eight months from opening with no difference in taste or quality. The reason for this is that the printed date is typically "best by" not "use by," which automatically gives you some wiggle room. Lower-protein flours like cake or pastry will last longer; higher-protein ones like whole wheat may start getting musty after six months or so. The exception to the rule is self-rising types—the baking powder in it will lose potency at around the same rate as the hard wheat. But across the board, if you refrigerate it, you can buy yourself up to two whole years.

How do I tell if my flour’s gone bad?

As with most food, the nose will know. If your flour smells off in a rancid, sour kind of way, chuck it—it’ll affect the flavor of what you make with it, and the last thing you want to do is suffer through a hard-won carb instead of enjoying it. And of course, if you find weevils, larvae, moths, or other types of ick in it, it’s time to restock. You can kill the eggs and bugs by freezing the flour to reduce the risk of infestation in the trash, but into the garbage it should absolutely go.

What is 00 flour?

In short: 00 flour (or double zero flour) is the silkiest, softest, finest ground flour you can get, prized by pizza makers and pasta slingers from Naples to New York and everywhere in between for the strength and elasticity of its meager gluten. Typically, this beautiful, powdery ingredient is imported, hence the 00 designation, which is rated according to Europe’s grind level ranking system versus American protein percentage categorization. What this means is that although 00 flours may have varying levels of protein (8 to 12 percent), they’ll all have in common low levels of germ, bran, and gluten and high levels of satisfying chewiness.

What’s the difference between hard and soft wheat?

Hard wheat, such as durum or winter-planted white and red is higher in protein and therefore has a hardier molecular structure. Because of that, it doesn’t break down as easily and has a more granular texture and a coarser grind. Soft wheat can also be red or white and is planted in the spring. It’s more tender because it blooms faster and younger, and can be milled to a softer, more powdery feel that's great for lower-gluten, less-structured baking projects.

How We Selected

Our team of editors and contributors spent hours researching the best flours on the market, evaluating their key features—like the type of wheat, protein content, and price—in addition to reviews from customers and other trusted sources. We then used our own knowledge and first-hand experiences to choose the items listed above.

Why Trust The Spruce Eats?

Su-Jit Lin has over a dozen years of experience in food writing and research and three times that in eating and comparing it with zeal. Her extensive travels have led her on singular scavenger hunts for the best and most authentic regional baked goods around the world, from the typical like croissants in Paris, pizza in Naples, and scones in Dublin to Sacher tortes in Vienna, pistachio paste cookies in Rome, pineapple buns in Hong Kong, and rusks in Cape Town. She’s a food science enthusiast and as such, an avid collector of ingredients known among friends to overflow her long-suffering pantry with things like single-purpose flour. She is not against gluten.

Amanda McDonaldis an editor at The Spruce Eats and has over seven years of experience researching, writing, and editing about all things food — from what new products are at the grocery store to chef-approved hacks that keep tricky leftovers fresh for days. She updated this story to include the most up-to-date information.

The 19 Best Cake Mix Cakes and Desserts

Updated by

Carrie Havranek

We Found the 13 Best Flours for Any Type of Recipe (15)

Carrie Havranek

Carrie has 10+ years experience as a food writer and editor. Her work can be found in her cookbook, Tasting Pennsylvania, and her site, the Dharma Kitchen.

Learn about The Spruce Eats'Editorial Process

and

Amanda McDonald

We Found the 13 Best Flours for Any Type of Recipe (16)

Amanda McDonald

Amanda McDonald is a journalist living in New York City and Commerce Updates Editor for The Spruce Eats. She has written and edited health, wellness, food, and fitness content as well as recipes for multiple publications.

Learn about The Spruce Eats'Editorial Process

Article Sources

The Spruce Eats uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.

  1. United States Department of Agriculture. Labeling organic products.

  2. Biesiekierski JR. What is gluten?.J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;32 Suppl 1:78-81. doi:10.1111/jgh.13703

  3. Food and Drug Administration. How GMOs are regulated for food and plant safety in the United States.

    1. Biesiekierski JR. What is gluten?.J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;32 Suppl 1:78-81.doi:10.1111/jgh.13703
  4. Biesiekierski JR. What is gluten?. J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;32 Suppl 1:78-81. doi:10.1111/jgh.13703

We Found the 13 Best Flours for Any Type of Recipe (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5479

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Birthday: 1995-01-14

Address: 55021 Usha Garden, North Larisa, DE 19209

Phone: +6812240846623

Job: Corporate Healthcare Strategist

Hobby: Singing, Listening to music, Rafting, LARPing, Gardening, Quilting, Rappelling

Introduction: My name is Foster Heidenreich CPA, I am a delightful, quaint, glorious, quaint, faithful, enchanting, fine person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.