Daniel Lissing Said He Left 'When Calls the Heart' for Reasons That "Are Very Personal to Me" (2024)

We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

Find out what he's been doing since playing Jack Thornton on the hit Hallmark show.

Daniel Lissing Said He Left 'When Calls the Heart' for Reasons That "Are Very Personal to Me" (1)By Amanda Garrity

Daniel Lissing Said He Left 'When Calls the Heart' for Reasons That "Are Very Personal to Me" (2)

  • Daniel Lissing left When Calls the Heart after playing Jack Thornton for five seasons.
  • His character tragically died in the season 5 finale, leaving Elizabeth completely heartbroken.
  • Some Hearties remain hopeful that Jack will make a return to the popular Hallmark show during season 8.

Hearties agree: When Calls the Heart hasn't been the same since the heartbreaking season 5 finale. At the tail-end of the Hallmark show's fifth season, Jack Thornton (played by Daniel Lissing) was on an assignment with a group of recruits when he was tragically killed by a landslide. Before he left, the Mountie wrote a letter to his wife Elizabeth (played by Erin Krakow) in fear that the assignment would be too much for his body to bear. The letter, which was shown in the finale episode, read:

"My dearest Elizabeth, I’m writing a letter I hope you never have to read. If you are, then you know I won’t be coming home. Take comfort that I will be watching over you for the rest of your days. I will always be with you in spirit. But I need you to promise me one thing, Elizabeth: you will open your heart to love again. Know that I want nothing more than your happiness. You are the perfect woman. You showed me what it feels like to be truly loved. For that, I am eternally grateful. Yours forever, Jack."

While the show has carried on and Elizabeth has opened her heart to another love (or two), many Hearties still want to know the reason behind Jacks' death. For Lissing, who played Jack for five seasons, this moment seemed like a natural progression for his career — and his character. "Circ*mstances arose for me where I needed to leave When Calls the Heart for reasons that are very personal to me," he said in a Facebook Live, according to Entertainment Tonight. "I went to Hallmark and they were nothing but supportive of me. I went to the girls and they were nothing but supportive of me."

At the time of his departure, his costars Erin Krakow and Lori Loughlin (who played Abigail Stanton on the show until she was written off the show in May 2019), opened up about how they really felt about Lissing's decision. "We are actors, and actors have contracts and sometimes those contracts expire and you have a choice to make," Loughlin explained to Entertainment Tonight. “You either renegotiate or you don’t, and Dan has chosen to move on, we respect that."

Krakow, who filmed most of her scenes with Lissing, responded straight from the heart: "I was just sad that Dan was leaving. That's the bottom line: We were all really sad about it, and that's hard," she reflected. "Dan, in many ways, has been my partner in crime for five years, and one of my greatest scene partners ever, and I'm just really gonna miss him."

When it came time for the writers and producers to figure out how to write off Jack's character, Loughlin admitted that death was the only option. "The only way he (Jack) would leave her (Elizabeth) is in death," she said. Luckily, the heartbreak was followed by some good news: At the start of season 6, Hearties learned that Elizabeth was pregnant with Jack's child a.k.a. baby Jack. Some fans even seem to think — okay, hope — that Jack will make a triumphant return to the show, whether it's in a flashback scene or as a ghost.

Even though he's off the show, Lissing is still a part of the Hallmark family, regularly posting photos with his former costars and behind-the-scenes moments on new Hallmark Channel projects. Still, he continues to rave about his experience playing Jack on the highest-rated Hallmark Channel show: "When I came out to the United States, as a guy who was playing [music] in bars in Sydney, to think that I would play a character like Jack on an American TV show is beyond anything I could've ever imagined."

Since his departure from the show, Lissing has gone on to play recurring characters on S.W.A.T. and The Rookie.

Daniel Lissing Said He Left 'When Calls the Heart' for Reasons That "Are Very Personal to Me" (4)

Amanda Garrity

Amanda Garrity is a lifestyle writer and editor with over seven years of experience, including five years on staff at Good Housekeeping, where she covered all things home and holiday, including the latest interior design trends, inspiring DIY ideas and gift guides for any (and every) occasion. She also has a soft spot for feel-good TV, so you can catch her writing about popular shows like Virgin River, Sweet Magnolias, Hallmark Channel’s When Calls the Heart and more.

This content is imported from OpenWeb. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.

Daniel Lissing Said He Left 'When Calls the Heart' for Reasons That "Are Very Personal to Me" (2024)

FAQs

Why did Daniel leave When Calls the Heart? ›

"We are actors, and actors have contracts and sometimes those contracts expire and you have a choice to make," Loughlin explained to Entertainment Tonight. “You either renegotiate or you don't, and Dan has chosen to move on, we respect that."

Why is Jack not coming back to When Calls the Heart? ›

Jack Thornton died in 'When Calls the Heart' Season 5

They killed off Jack, who ended up dying in a tragic mine collapse accident at the end of season 5. It was a devasting blow for Jack's new wife Elizabeth (Erin Krakow), who gave birth to the couple's first child not long after his death.

Did they change Jack on When Calls the Heart? ›

After the Taylor twins' exit, the part of baby Jack on When Calls the Heart was recast with a different pint-sized actor: Hyland Goodrich. He made his TV debut in the season 9 premiere, and has charmed audiences in every episode since. He's also won over his co-stars.

Who does Jack marry in When Calls the Heart? ›

Elizabeth Thornton (Wife): It was a lukewarm beginning to their friendship when he was first posted to Coal Valley. After a five-season long romance, Jack married Elizabeth in a beautiful wedding.

Does Lori Loughlin return to When Calls the Heart? ›

When asked by Showbiz Cheat Sheet in October 2021 whether Loughlin's appearance in When Hope Calls would lead to her returning to When Calls the Heart, a Hallmark spokesperson replied, "Hallmark Channel has not cast Lori Loughlin in any current projects, including When Calls the Heart, nor do we have any plans to cast ...

Is Jack coming back to When Hope Calls? ›

Daniel Lissing shocked Hearties when he chose to exit When Calls the Heart three years ago — and even he's surprised to say that he's returning as Jack Thornton for the season 2 premiere of the spinoff, When Hope Calls.

Who replaced Jack on When Calls the Heart? ›

A new face will be joining the When Calls the Heart cast in season 9. Hyland Goodrich will take over the role of little Jack when the Hallmark Channel series returns in 2022, replacing twins Lincoln and Gunnar Taylor.

Did they replace Abigail on When Calls the Heart? ›

Many assumed that her character would head back to Hope Valley to join Elizabeth (Erin Krakow), Lucas (Chris McNally) and the rest of the crew on When Calls the Heart (makes sense!), but, in fact, Lori will reprise her role as Abigail on When Hope Calls, set to return for season 2 on a new network, GAC Family.

What age is Daniel Lissing? ›

Will Rosemary have a baby on When Calls the Heart? ›

Rosemary feels the baby move and finally tells Lee she is pregnant. All seasons of the original, romantic show are now available to stream! Rosemary feels the baby move and finally tells Lee she is pregnant. Joseph agrees to speak with Minnie's father, allowing them to put their troubles…

Does Elizabeth have Jack's baby on When Calls the Heart? ›

Season 6. In the Christmas special before Season 6, she gives birth to Jack Jr., named after her late husband. While she initially struggles with Jack's absence, she eventually becomes thankful for little Jack as a way to remember him.

Is Abigail coming back to When Calls the Heart season 9? ›

Lori Loughlin isn't returning to Hallmark Channel

Abigail was a beloved When Calls the Heart character.

Who does Rosemary marry in When Calls the Heart? ›

In late Season 3, she and Lee are married and continue living together in Hope Valley.

Who does Elizabeth end up with on When Calls the Heart? ›

Hearties, there's a lot of romance on the horizon in Hope Valley. In the final moments of When Calls the Heart season 8, Elizabeth (played by Erin Krakow) put the much-debated love triangle behind her and realized that Lucas (played by Chris McNally) is the one who calls her heart.

Does Elizabeth and Jack marry? ›

Elizabeth and Jack got married in When Calls the Heart's Season 5. Sadly, the couple's Hallmark romance ended tragically when Jack was killed off-screen the same season. Former When Calls the Heart star, Lori Loughlin, previously explained the decision to have him depart in death.

Is Hallmark Cancelled When Calls the Heart? ›

The good news for Hallmark fans is that When Calls the Heart has been renewed for a 10th season. The bad news? They won't see it anytime soon. Hallmark Media Exec VP President of Programming Lisa Hamilton Daly told reporters at the Television Critics Tour today that the series won't return until the middle of 2023.

What happened to the actress in When Calls the Heart? ›

Lori Loughlin was dropped from When Calls the Heart after her alleged involvement in the college admissions scandal. The network took a brief break to cut her out of the show.

Where did Jesse go on When Calls the Heart? ›

Aren has portrayed Jesse's character since the Season 3 premiere in December 2015. He revealed that he was leaving the show back in December 2021. Since then, he has signed on for a short film, a feature film, and a TV series.

Who is not coming back to When Hope Calls? ›

Is Grace going to be in When Hope Calls season 2? While Lillian will be back with Morgan Kohan reprising the role she originated in When Calls the Heart and later in When Hope Calls, it appears that Jocelyn Hudon will not be returning as Grace in the show's second season.

Does Abigail marry in When Calls the Heart? ›

Abigail Stanton is one of the first widows we see in the pilot episode of When Calls the Heart. She moved to Coal Valley (now Hope Valley) several years before with her husband Noah and son Peter.

Has When Hope Calls been Cancelled? ›

Season One Ratings

Find out how When Hope Calls stacks up against other Hallmark Channel TV shows. When Hope Calls has been renewed for a second season on GAC Family which will debut on December 18, 2021.

Will When Calls the Heart be back in 2023? ›

Hallmark Media's executive vice president of programming announced at the Television Critics Tour in August 2022 that the show won't return until mid-2023.

Who is Elizabeth's baby in When Calls the Heart? ›

Jack was first played by twins Henry & Hudson Anderson, then by twins Lincoln & Gunnar Taylor, and he is now currently by Hyland Goodrich.

How old is Allie on When Calls the Heart? ›

Biography. Allison "Allie" Grant she is the 10 year old niece of Constable Nathan Grant. Her mother died when Allie was only four years old; and her father left her shortly after, she was then left in the custody of her uncle Nathan.

How did they explain Abigail leaving When Calls the Heart? ›

How did When Calls the Heart explain Abigail's absence from Hope Valley? The exit of her character was a simple one—Abigail's mother fell ill and Abigail left Hope Valley (with her adopted son, Cody) to head back east to take care of her. This left the door open for her character's return.

Will Abigail come back to Days of Our Lives? ›

The week of September 26, 2022

This week, look for Marci Miller to resurface as the late Abigail DiMera.

Who is the new Abigail Stanton on When Calls the Heart? ›

Lori Loughlin is staging a comeback. The Full House vet is set to return to the When Calls the Heart universe as Abigail Stanton in the spinoff When Hope Calls, which is moving to a new network, GAC Family (fka Great American Country Network), for Season 2. 2021 Christmas Movie Guide: 115+ Originals!

What movies is Daniel Lissing in? ›

Daniel Lissing

How tall is David Lissing? ›

Does Erin Krakow sing Danny Boy in When Calls the Heart? ›

Although it looked like Elizabeth was going to be a no show at the last moment she appeared to sing Danny Boy just like she had promised. Erin's singing performance absolutely blew me away.

What episode does Rosemary get pregnant? ›

In the "Never Say Never" episode that aired, appropriately, on Mother's Day, Rosemary's stomach bug turned out to be something much different when she learned she might be pregnant with the couple's first child.

Why is Cody not on When Calls the Heart? ›

We last saw Cody on the episode “Heart of a Mountie” in 2019. That episode aired in May 2019. Cody's appearance happened after “When Calls the Heart” took a small break to deal with the creative decisions following Loughlin's departure.

Who is the mother of Lucas in When Calls the Heart? ›

Teryl Rothery: Helen Bouchard.

Who does Elizabeth marry after Jack? ›

That moment, which comes just moments after Elizabeth joyfully agrees to marry Lucas, was an improvisation crafted by McNally. He says with a smile, “It felt like the moment deserved a twirl, so yes. You ever have those moments in your life where you're like, 'This is a twirl moment? ' It was one of those.”

Where is Hamilton in When Calls the Heart? ›

Hamilton is a Canadian port city on the western tip of Lake Ontario. Hamilton has been featured in Season Two of When Calls the Heart. When Elizabeth Thatcher and Jack Thornton went to Hamilton to visit their families.

What episode does Jack get killed in When Calls the Heart? ›

Close to My Heart | When Calls the Heart.

What happened to Abigail's son Peter on When Calls the Heart? ›

Peter was the son of Noah and Abigail Stanton. He died alongside his father when the coal mine collapse that took place before Season 1.

Is Lori Loughlin returning to the Hallmark Channel? ›

What's more, Hallmark Channel stopped airing Lori's shows and movies, including Garage Sale Mysteries. But three years after the headline-making trial, it appears that Hallmark is bringing back her projects.

Who is the new character on When Calls the Heart? ›

Hyland Goodrich (Little Jack Thornton)

Goodrich takes over the role of little Jack Thornton from twins, Lincoln and Gunnar Taylor, who played Baby Thornton for three seasons.

Who is Nora in When Calls the Heart? ›

Kristina Wagner: Nora Avery.

Who is Sophia on When Calls the Heart? ›

Andrea Brooks
BornAndrea K. Brooks March 3, 1989 Brantford, Ontario, Canada
OccupationActress model
Years active2006–present
Children1

Who is pregnant on When Calls the Heart? ›

(Exclusive) Paging Dr. Carter, there's a baby on the way! Andrea Brooks, who plays the beloved Hope Valley doctor on When Calls the Heart, exclusively opens up to ET's Deidre Behar about expecting her second little one.

What happens in finale of When Calls the Heart? ›

Season 9 finale of "When Calls the Heart." Elizabeth confronts Lucas as she needs to know if he is leaving Hope Valley or if he… is planning to propose. Minnie is upset by Joseph's unwillingness to accept her father's help. Fiona's ability to run the oil company comes into question as Arthur asks her out to dinner.

What happens to Bill in When Calls the Heart? ›

Bill quits being a mountie because he feels he works best when he doesn't answer to anyone. He spends this season helping people out in Hope Valley.

Does Jack Sparrow have a crush on Elizabeth? ›

Their relationship is indeed platonic (more like chaotic) even after she let him kiss her. After all the adventures that they have been through, both of them are still willing to sacrifice one another to save themselves. A classic example would be Elizabeth cuffing Jack Sparrow to the ship as a sacrifice to the Kraken.

Does Elizabeth choose Jack or Will? ›

Throughout the original trilogy, Elizabeth Swann is the central point of a triangle formed by Will Turner, Jack Sparrow, and James Norrington. The films end with Elizabeth choosing Will — but was he the right choice?

Why was Jack missing from season 4 of When Calls the Heart? ›

"Circ*mstances arose for me where I needed to leave When Calls the Heart for reasons that are very personal to me," he said in a Facebook Live, according to Entertainment Tonight. "I went to Hallmark and they were nothing but supportive of me. I went to the girls and they were nothing but supportive of me."

Why did Abigail and Cody leave When Calls the Heart? ›

The exit of her character was a simple one—Abigail's mother fell ill and Abigail left Hope Valley (with her adopted son, Cody) to head back east to take care of her.

Who did not return to When Calls the Heart? ›

Aren Buchholz and Eva Bourne announced their departure from When Calls the Heart weeks before the Season 9 premiere — which gave fans enough time to mentally prepare for an episode without their favorite couple. "I'm excited about Season 9 of When Calls the Heart, but I am going to miss Clara and Jesse on the show.

Was When Calls the Heart Cancelled? ›

They won't see it anytime soon. Hallmark Media Exec VP President of Programming Lisa Hamilton Daly told reporters at the Television Critics Tour today that the series won't return until the middle of 2023. The network renewed the drama in June and announced that Lindsay Sturman (Supergirl) will take over as showrunner.

What happens to Henry in When Calls the Heart? ›

He found Christopher's name in some papers Henry left at the oil company when Lucas took it over to keep it from going bankrupt. Henry and Lucas made up after Lucas confessed his role in bringing Christopher to town and Henry was last seen at the end of season 8 leaving Hope Valley, destination unknown.

Will Cody be back on When Calls the Heart? ›

Is Cody Stanton returning to 'When Calls the Heart' next season? Probably not. Per Heavy.com, Ryan visited the set for fun — not because he was joining the show again. Cast members revealed on social media that Ryan was not on set for filming.

Who does Abigail Stanton marry? ›

Background. Abigail Stanton is one of the first widows we see in the pilot episode of When Calls the Heart. She moved to Coal Valley (now Hope Valley) several years before with her husband Noah and son Peter.

Does Elizabeth Thatcher marry Jack in When Calls the Heart? ›

Elizabeth finally marries Jack but their happiness together does not last long. In the final two episodes of season five, a Mountie arrives in Coal Valley with news that Jack was killed in a landslide.

Is Rosemary on When Calls the Heart pregnant? ›

All seasons of the original, romantic show are now available to stream! Rosemary feels the baby move and finally tells Lee she is pregnant. Joseph agrees to speak with Minnie's father, allowing them to put their troubles…

Why is Carson not on When Calls the Heart? ›

In the show, Carson actually left Hope Valley to pursue a fellowship in Baltimore after he and Faith (Andrea Brooks) decided to end their relationship. At the moment, it doesn't seem like he will be back for season nine either.

Will there be a When Calls the Heart Christmas Special 2022? ›

Hearties will be without a new When Calls the Heart Christmas movie again in 2022. But there are plenty of other holiday films to enjoy on Hallmark Channel, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries and other networks like Lifetime, UPtv, CBS, and Great American Family.

Is Henry coming back to When Calls the Heart? ›

Abigail is surprised to find Henry back in Hope Valley so soon. All seasons of the original, romantic show are now available to stream! Rosemary feels the baby move and finally tells Lee she is pregnant.

How did When Calls the Heart end? ›

Rosemary feels the baby move and finally tells Lee she is pregnant. Joseph agrees to speak with Minnie's father, allowing them to put their troubles… behind them.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Corie Satterfield

Last Updated:

Views: 6266

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Corie Satterfield

Birthday: 1992-08-19

Address: 850 Benjamin Bridge, Dickinsonchester, CO 68572-0542

Phone: +26813599986666

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Table tennis, Soapmaking, Flower arranging, amateur radio, Rock climbing, scrapbook, Horseback riding

Introduction: My name is Corie Satterfield, I am a fancy, perfect, spotless, quaint, fantastic, funny, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.