You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies (2024)

The silver sprinkles have been controversial for decades.

By
You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies (1)You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies (2)

Country Living editors select each product featured. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Why Trust Us?

Not to ruin your Christmas cookie eating extravaganza, but you may want to think twice the next time you're about to bite into a holiday treat covered in silver sugar pearls.

The sparkling balls, formally known as silver dragées, have been causing quite the stir in the baking world for over 100 years. While it's technically legal to sell silver dragées in most states across the U.S., the Food and Drug Administration does not recommend ingesting them. In fact, all brands selling them must label the sprinkles as "for decoration only" and the baking baubles cannot be labeled as edible, according to The Huffington Post.

It was back in 1906 that the Food and Drug Administration outlawed all metallic food ingredients, including these shiny balls. But even today, the scientific research regarding their safety is still a bit blurry. While there's no evidence proving these sprinkles are poisonous or harmful when eaten in reasonable amounts, silver has been proven to be dangerous when consumed in large quantities. And in 1970, the FDA published a statement warning consumers that dragées could make your skin appear a blue-gray color if you ate too many. Yikes!

Now, you can only find silver dragées in stores and online labeled as decorations—unless you live in California, where they're illegal. The state banned them in 2003 after one customer sued an in-state cake decorator for selling baked goods adorned with dragées, claiming they posed a threat to children oblivious to the potential dangers.

Despite the lawsuit, experts still argue that dragées probably won't harm you. "We are not aware of any health problems associated with this product," Lea Brooks, a spokesperson for the California Department of Health Services, told SFGate.com in 2003. "Levels of the metal are extremely low—you'd have to consume massive quantities. We don't know how much."

You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies (5)You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies (6)

But when it comes to Christmas cookie decorating, there are obviously lots of other safe options out there. You can experiment with classic candies like M&Ms, seasonal treats like peppermint Hershey's Kisses or mints, or other fun Christmas sprinkles. And if you just can't live without a little sparkle on your dessert, try a dash of edible glitter.

BUY NOW: Silver dragées ($7, amazon.com)

(h/t The Huffington Post)

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies (2024)

FAQs

You Should Never, Ever Eat Those Silver Sprinkles on Your Christmas Cookies? ›

The silver balls of sugar known as dragees are actually not supposed to be eaten, according to the Food and Drug Administration. While they are non toxic, the FDA has not approved any decorations containing silver for consumption.

Are silver sprinkles safe to eat? ›

While silver has been banned as a food-coloring additive since 1906, FDA guidelines say that the silver dragees can be used for decoration, but they are deemed unsafe for human consumption.

Why are silver dragees not edible? ›

The most serious result of ingesting silver is a condition called argyria, the federal agency said. If you eat or breathe in silver compounds over a long period of time (several months to many years), your skin and other body tissues can turn gray or blue-gray.

Why are dragees illegal in California? ›

When dragees came back into fashion in 2003, he filed a lawsuit alleging silver dragees are toxic. Since then, retail stores, wholesalers and Internet suppliers won't sell dragees to anyone in California because of the fear of being sued.

What are silver ball sprinkles called? ›

The sparkling balls, formally known as silver dragées, have been causing quite the stir in the baking world for over 100 years.

Is edible silver safe to eat? ›

Large quantities of ingested bioactive silver can cause argyria, but the use of edible silver or gold as vark is not considered harmful to the body, since the metal is in inert form (not ionic bioactive form), and the quantities involved in normal use are minuscule.

Can you chew on silver? ›

If silver is eaten or inhaled, it leaves the body in waste matter in about a week. Some of the silver that is eaten, inhaled, or passes through the skin may build up in many places in the body. Repeated exposures to silver compounds can cause skin and other body tissues to turn gray or blue-gray.

What is edible silver dust made of? ›

The ingredients vary by brand and color, so there is no uniformity to the contents of luster dust. Commonly cited ingredients are titanium dioxide, iron oxide, carmine, and mica. Additionally, some contain iron blue or chromium oxide.

What is edible silver glitter made of? ›

Many glitter products clearly state "edible" and contain ingredients like sugar, cornstarch and approved color additives. Those are safe to consume, so go ahead and get glittery!

Why are sweets called dragees? ›

According to an unverified legend, it has it that a confectioner named Julius Dragatus served honey-covered almonds called dragati at weddings and births. When sugar became more readily available in the 15th century, the nuts were coated in sugar instead.

Are sprinkles bad for you? ›

Sprinkles are particularly high in sugar. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) recommends limiting your sugar intake to under 10% of your total daily calories. On a 2,000-calorie diet, this equals around 12 teaspoons (50 grams) per day ( 5 ).

Can you eat sugar pearls? ›

Yes. But Taste HARD, Be Careful and melt it in your mouth rather than bite it. Put these Edible Gold Sugar Pearls Candy Sprinkles on cookies or cupcake toppers after baking to avoid melting.

What are the little silver balls on cakes? ›

Silver dragees are often used as a decorative element in baked goods such as cookies and cakes. These metal balls are made of sugar and coated with a metallic coating, usually silver or gold.

Why are some sprinkles illegal? ›

American sprinkles containing coal tar dyes are banned, because even unhealthy sugar products can't contain certain ingredients in the EU and the UK.

What is English slang for sprinkles? ›

In British English, these are sugar strands or hundreds-and-thousands (the latter term alludes to their supposed uncountability). In the New England region of United States, as well as in Philadelphia, sprinkles are often referred to as jimmies.

What do the British call sprinkles? ›

Sprinkles have many names in many countries. In England, they are called “hundreds and thousands.” In Holland, they go by hagelslag. By most accounts, sprinkles were invented by French bakers in the 18th Century and called nonpareils.

What is edible silver dust? ›

Our silver-tinted Rhinestone Silver Edible Shimmer is a versatile pearlescent fine dust that creates a dimensional opaque metallic finish on food. Brush it on dry for high shine, or mix with extracts and spirits to create edible paint. It's 100% FDA-approved for consumption and is completely odorless and flavorless.

Can you eat on silver? ›

Sterling silver actually has anti-bacterial properties, and is completely safe to use with food.

Is it safe to eat sprinkles? ›

Consuming sprinkles in moderation is recommended, as they are high in calories and sugar.

What are silver balls for cakes made of? ›

Ingredients - Sugar, wheat starch, maltodextrin, fish gelatine, colouring agent E174.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Roderick King

Last Updated:

Views: 5869

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Roderick King

Birthday: 1997-10-09

Address: 3782 Madge Knoll, East Dudley, MA 63913

Phone: +2521695290067

Job: Customer Sales Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Embroidery, Parkour, Kitesurfing, Rock climbing, Sand art, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Roderick King, I am a cute, splendid, excited, perfect, gentle, funny, vivacious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.